Skip to main content

Faith After Doubt: - Doubting Brian-A Review

 


Doubting Brian

Faith After Doubt:

Why Your Beliefs Stopped Working and What to Do About It

By

  Brian D. McLaren

Reviewed by

  Geoffrey W. Sutton

Faith After Doubt reads like a spiritual memoir and, no doubt, many will find Brain’s ideas helpful. He writes well, and judging by various reviews online, he has met the needs of a lot of followers.

For young thoughtful Christians doubt can be an unwelcome guest who stays too long and keeps returning as if doubt were oblivious to the not so subtle rejection of a hostile host. McLaren embraces doubt as a catalyst to spiritual growth. His welcoming attitude toward doubt may help those struggling to close the door.

Some readers appear to have appreciated his four-stages of faith, which are frequently referred to in the book. Here’s a quick look.

1. Simplicity- Christians accept the simple faith they have been taught and many remain in that stage their entire life.

2. Complexity- Christians are learning about their faith. They are thinking and asking questions.

3. Perplexity- Christians develop scepticism regarding official teachings and churches.

4. Harmony- Christians find peace. They no longer worry about unanswered questions. Spirituality is experienced as a deep love for others and a deep connectedness with people and nature.

If the message about doubt helps, by all means read the book. If the stages of spirituality help frame your spiritual journey, then this book may be helpful. I have found some of his other books to be more interesting.

My primary difficulties with Faith After Doubt are twofold. First, His stage theory is not convincing. The stages are not supported by evidence or an in-depth analysis of the struggles of dozens or hundreds of people sharing a set of distinctive features. The flow from one stage to another is too imprecise and the role of doubt needs more clarity.

Second, he does not plumb the depths of the pain people experience during their bouts with doubt that rock their childlike faith. Brian’s discussion is too cognitive. I’m looking for that depth of emotion that plagues so many intelligent Christians. And I want to know the different ways they come to grips with spirituality.

I come to this book from a different perspective than those who have not studied religiosity from a scientific perspective or treated people whose mental health has been affected by their faith. So, I do not wish to overly critical of Brian’s work, which I hope helps a lot of people. For those looking for a more academic approach, see the writings of Julie Exline on spiritual struggles.

 

Geoffrey W. Sutton, PhD is Emeritus Professor of Psychology. He retired from a clinical practice and was credentialed in clinical neuropsychology and psychopharmacology. His website is  www.suttong.com

 

See Geoffrey Sutton’s books on   AMAZON       or  GOOGLE STORE

Follow on    FACEBOOK   Geoff W. Sutton    

   TWITTER  @Geoff.W.Sutton    

You can read many published articles at no charge:

  Academia   Geoff W Sutton     ResearchGate   Geoffrey W Sutton 

 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Great Sex Rescue – Challenging Harmful Evangelical Messages

  The Great Sex Rescue – Challenging Harmful Evangelical Messages   By Sheila Wray Gregoire, Rebecca Gregoire Lindenbach, & Joanna Sawatsky   Reviewed by   Geoffrey W. Sutton Review Summary The Great Sex Rescue is an evangelical Christian approach that challenges messages in several other Christian sex books, which do not focus on the sexual pleasure of women. In addition, the three writers challenge messages that emphasize dutiful wives meeting their husband’s sex needs regardless of how she feels or what aspects of a sexual experience would bring her more wholistic pleasure. T he authors offer a more woman-friendly interpretation of  biblical texts that have been interpreted in unfriendly ways. More troubling are Christian sexual activity messages that may encourage men to simply use their wives for their pleasure or even abuse them. After explaining their concerns, the authors offer suggestions for better sex including addressing medical p...
Post a Comment
Read more

Rape as Power: Revisiting Susan Brownmiller’s Against Our Will in Historical and Cultural Context

    Against Our Will: Men, Women, and Rape       by Susan Brownmiller   Reviewed by   Geoffrey W. Sutton Abstract  Susan Brownmiller’s Against Our Will: Men, Women, and Rape (2013), originally published in 1975, reframed rape as a political act of power and control rather than an isolated crime of passion. Drawing on history, law, warfare, slavery, racial politics, prisons, and cultural and victim narratives, Brownmiller argued that rape functions as a conscious tool of domination. This review summarizes her central arguments, highlights the book’s historical and cultural significance, and provides a historical framework against which we can measure progress or the lack thereof (Sutton, 2025, October 1). Keywords: rape, feminism, sexual violence, power, gender, survivor advocacy   CITE THIS REVIEW Sutton, G. W. (2025, October 1). Rape as Power: Revisiting Susan Brownmiller’s Against Our Will in Historical and Cultural Context....
Post a Comment
Read more

Reconsidering Missionary Childhoods: A Critical Engagement with Fletcher’s The Missionary Kids

  The Missionary Kids   By Holly Berkley Fletcher Reviewed By   Geoffrey W. Sutton The Missionary Kids Abstract In The Missionary Kids: Unmasking the Myths of White Evangelicalism (2025), Holly Berkley Fletcher combines memoir, oral history, and historical analysis to examine the lived realities of missionary children (MKs). Drawing on her upbringing in Kenya and interviews with other MKs, Fletcher challenges romanticized portrayals of missionary life by exposing the cultural dislocation, spiritual neglect, and emotional burdens often carried by children in missionary families. The book is structured around four parts: the myth of parents as martyrs, the imposed nature of missionary “calling,” the spiritual neglect of MKs in boarding schools, and the collective testimony of resilience and loss. Fletcher’s dual perspective as both historian and former CIA analyst enriches her critique of evangelical institutions and their impact on children. This work contributes to schola...
Post a Comment
Read more