Skip to main content

Psychology and Christianity: Five Views -Review

 

Five Views 2024
Geoffrey W Sutton & Bing AI

The second edition of Psychology and Christianity: Five Views is an expanded version of the 2000 edition. Edited by Eric L. Johnson, the book presents ways to understand the relationship between psychology and Christianity.

 [Available on Amazon]

The Five Views

 

1. Levels-of-Explanation View by David Myers, Hope College

 This view suggests that psychology and Christianity operate at different levels of explanation. Psychology operates at the level of human behavior and mental processes, while Christianity operates at the level of meaning and value.

 

2. Integration View by Stanton Jones, Wheaton College

 This view proposes that psychology and Christianity can be integrated in a way that both can contribute to a fuller understanding of human nature.

 

3. Christian Psychology View by Robert Roberts (Baylor University) and P. J. Watson (University of Tennessee-Chattanooga)

 This view argues that a distinctly Christian psychology is needed, one that is grounded in the teachings of the Bible and informed by a Christian understanding of human nature.

 

4. Transformational Psychology View by John Coe and Todd Hall, Rosemeade Graduate School of Psychology

 This view emphasizes the transformative power of Christianity and suggests that psychological change must involve spiritual transformation.

 

5. Biblical Counseling View by David Powlison, Westminister Theological Seminary

 This view argues that the Bible provides the most accurate and helpful guidance for counseling, and that secular psychology should be used cautiously.

 

The authors present their viewpoints with humility, understanding the complexity of relating psychology and Christianity. The first two views focus on clear descriptions and arguments, while the last three views provide practical illustrations and examples, considering the real-world application of psychology. The book has become a standard introductory textbook for students and professors of Christian psychology.

 


APA Reference:

Johnson, E. L. (Ed.). (2010). Psychology and Christianity: Five Views (2nd ed.). Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic.

Available on AMAZON

Reflections

I approached this text with my usual analytic approach to opinion articles. I earned my PhD in psychology at the University of Missouri-Columbia at a time when the emphasis was on the science of psychology, which embraced the scientific experiment as the gold standard for obtaining reliable evidence about human nature. It was not a faith-unfriendly place. At least four of the faculty I routinely encountered identified as Christian and so did several students. Nevertheless, religion and spirituality were not included in the curriculum. At the time, mid-1970s, only a few psychologists had written about Christianity and psychology and they focused on psychotherapy rather than psychological science.

Although I could understand the importance of faith to patients in psychotherapy, other aspects of psychological science seemed removed from such discussions. For example, how would a Christian perspective change what we learned about the functioning of the brain, the assessment of brain functions, and the problems associated with brain injuries? As another example, I wondered how it would make a difference in psychological evaluations. Christian and non-Christian psychologists administered the same tests to Christian and non-Christian patients, scored them the same way, referred to the same criteria for diagnoses, and made recommendations for interventions based on the best available treatments.

Psychological science deals with the natural world. Christianity includes the supernatural realm, which is beyond the scope of psychology. Sometimes psychology and Christianity do offer perspectives on the same or similar topics like parenting, marriage, alcohol abuse, and forgiveness. Although, Christians often differ among themselves and with psychological findings on the best way to parent, treat alcohol dependence or abuse, and deal with the expression of forgiveness and the related concept of reconciliation.  

A full integration or a full reconciliation of Christianity and psychological science does not yet exist. And in my view, there are too many nonoverlapping concerns to have a synthesis that most Christian scholars would say yields a fully integrated model. After all, serious thinkers have addressed the topic for several decades. Furthermore, I suggest that Christians often end up reinterpreting the scriptures to accommodate a scientific finding such as the evidence supporting a combination of cognitive-behavioral therapy and psychopharmacology to treat depression.

Regardless of my concerns about a viable model of integration or a reconciliation of Christianity and psychology, I do think this book or a similar set of views is worth considering by graduate students who wish to understand different perspectives on the relationship between faith and psychology.

Related posts

Evolution, Psychology, and Christianity: Irreconcilable Differences



Geoffrey W. Sutton, PhD is Emeritus Professor of Psychology. He retired from a clinical practice and was credentialed in clinical neuropsychology and psychopharmacology. His website is  www.suttong.com

 

See Geoffrey Sutton’s books on   AMAZON       or  GOOGLE STORE

Follow on    FACEBOOK   Geoff W. Sutton    

   TWITTER  @Geoff.W.Sutton    

You can read many published articles at no charge:

  Academia   Geoff W Sutton     ResearchGate   Geoffrey W Sutton 




Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Denial of Death and the Meaningful Life- Book Review

  The Denial of Death   by Ernest Becker A Review by Geoffrey W. Sutton The prospect of death, Dr. Johnson said, wonderfully concentrates the mind. The main thesis of this book is that it does much more than that: the idea of death, the fear of it, haunts the human animal like nothing else; it is a mainspring of human activity—activity designed largely to avoid the fatality of death, to overcome it by denying in some way that it is the final destiny for man.  — Ernest Becker, xvii I completed a recent reading of this old classic yesterday (13 December, 2015) because I was interested in Becker’s contribution to Terror Management Theory, which I find so helpful in understanding the ways U.S. leaders are publicly responding to terrorist activities. Becker’s ideas are more than forty years old and many have not withstood the test of time. However, his basic premise that we deny the reality of death in many ways remains valid
3 comments
Read more

A Christmas Carol offers lessons in Psychology and Faith A Book Review

A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens A Review by Geoffrey W. Sutton My copy of A Christmas Carol was a gift on Christmas day, 1963. Two Christmases before I had walked the cold, fog-laden, smog drenched streets of Old London with my dad whilst my mother visited with her family. It was a grey day and a grey week. We took turns warming parts of our body by fireplaces here and there. After five years in the U.S. we had returned home to London on the occasion of my maternal grandmother’s death.  Dickens’ story paints a familiar tale textured by my early memories and enriched today by having watched my favourite rendition of A Christmas Carol ( 1984 ) with my wife on Christmas eve. My interest in reviewing the book is not just for a pleasant walk about the old streets of London but I'm motivated by a sense of appreciation for the poetic and colourful artistry with which Dickens plumbs the hopes and fears of humanity. So, follow
Post a Comment
Read more

WILLPOWER Setting & Reaching Goals- Book Review by Sutton

WILLPOWER Rediscovering the Greatest    Human Strength By Roy Baumeister & John Tierney Reviewed by Geoffrey W. Sutton I go to a gym, which is crowded in January. Regulars know the early Happy-New-Year commitments to fitness will weaken sometime in February. Roy Baumeister has spent a good part of his career studying self-control. His book, Willpower   written with Tierney,  entertains and informs us with an organized set of findings explaining factors that influence self-control. Two critical factors weaken our judgments: food and sleep. We need glucose and sleep to be at our best when it comes to making wise decisions and marking progress toward our goals. A pretty woman can loosen a man’s grip on his career--we hear these news stories from time to time as one political group takes aim at each other's leaders--men who failed at sexual self-control and sadly blame women for their lack of self-control. Fat shaming happens. T
Post a Comment
Read more